Since I listened to Mark Rosewater’s podcast on what went wrong with Homelands (can be found here: http://media.wizards.com/podcasts/magic/drivetowork25Homelands.mp3 ) I got to thinking why not redesign Homelands to function properly for draft while keeping with the great flavor. Now instead of making a Homelands 2, this project is to find ways to “fix” the original, which is why I am calling it Homelands 1.1. I hope this can turn into a community effort to help better understand Magic’s past and to inspired continuing creative and flavorful design in the future.
The first step with be to redesign the individual cards, many of which are printed in near nonfunctional ways or at costs that far exceed their function. Some try to be flavorful with abilities that don’t really make sense. Second, these cards need to be judged in the context of each other, as there is no point in having a bunch of cards that don’t work together. Third, if we get there, would be playtesting.
Starting with individual design, I hope to post five cards a post for discussion and improvement. I will post both the original and my alterations. In the spirit of the set, I will try to stick with the power level of the era but with be open to using all tool at my disposal we have today, such as keywords and understanding of the color pie. I am interested to hear what you think and hope you would go about this.
Today’s cards are the first five of the set. Note, I will be rendering my versions in modern card frames for clarity:
Let me know what you think!